Dissertation

This is one dissertation rubric. It combines the academic-review list, the subject-matter list, and the evaluation list, and it drops items that belong to a single school. A manuscript usually has front matter (title page, abstract, table of contents), five chapters, references, and any appendices, in APA 7. Chapter 1 introduces the problem, purpose, framework, research questions, significance, and key terms. Chapter 2 explains the search and reviews the literature by theme, including the framework. Chapter 3 describes the design, sample, instruments, procedures, analysis, and ethics in enough detail to repeat the study. Chapter 4 reports results by research question and compares them with the literature. Chapter 5 discusses the findings, makes recommendations, and closes with a conclusion.

An uploaded template is added beside this type. It does not replace it. 40 criteria.

Headings

#CriterionMeetsPartially meetsDoes not meet
1 Chapter 1 opening
The chapter opens by orienting the reader and is supported by literature.
2 Problem
The problem is specific and supported by recent scholarly sources.
3 Purpose
The purpose matches the problem and says how the study was conducted.
4 Framework introduction
The framework is named and explained with literature.
5 Nature of the study
Design, variables or constructs, instruments, analysis, and the reason for that choice are stated.
6 Research questions
Questions are aligned, measurable, and not yes-or-no questions.
7 Hypotheses
Quantitative studies pair each research question with a null and an alternative hypothesis. Qualitative studies do not need hypotheses.
8 Significance
The contribution of the study is supported by current literature.
9 Key terms
Definitions are cited and listed in alphabetical order.
10 Chapter 1 summary
The summary restates the need, purpose, and method, and leads into Chapter 2.
11 Chapter 2 opening and search
The chapter is outlined, and the search names databases, terms, and a date range.
12 Literature breadth
The review is long enough for a dissertation and uses current sources.
13 Full framework
The framework is developed in detail, including why it was chosen over others.
14 Literature themes
Themes move from broad to narrow and weigh where studies agree and disagree.
15 Chapter 2 summary
The summary gathers the themes and leads into the method.
16 Chapter 3 opening
The chapter orients the reader and previews its sections.
17 Method and design
The method and design fit the questions, cite methodology sources, and discuss alternatives.
18 Population and sample
The population, inclusion criteria, and, for quantitative work, a cited power analysis are present.
19 Instrumentation
Each instrument’s reliability, validity, and source or permission is described.
20 Data collection
Sample, procedures, analysis, ethics, and the researcher’s role are present.
21 Replication detail
Procedures and analysis are specific enough for another researcher to repeat the study.
22 Chapter 4 opening
The chapter restates the purpose and is organized by research question.
23 Validity and reliability of the data
The chapter reports trustworthiness or the checks required by the statistical tests.
24 Results
Results are organized by research question and stay descriptive.
25 Evaluation of findings
Findings are compared with the literature and the framework.
26 Chapter 4 summary
The chapter closes with the key results and leads into Chapter 5.
27 Chapter 5 opening
The chapter orients the reader and previews its sections.
28 Discussion
Each research question is discussed in light of the literature, the problem, and the framework.
29 Recommendations for practice
Practice recommendations come from the findings and the literature.
30 Recommendations for future research
Future studies are tied to this study’s limitations and the literature.
31 Conclusions
The close restates the study and leaves a clear take-home message.
32 Abstract
The abstract states the problem, purpose, procedures, results, implications, and recommendations.
33 Citations
Claims use current scholarly sources and avoid informal wording.
34 References
In-text citations and the reference list match, without duplicates or broken DOI links.
35 Appendices
Appendices that are mentioned appear in the order they are first mentioned.
36 Tense
A completed study is written in the past tense.
37 APA format
Contents lists and citations follow APA 7.
38 Writing
The voice is formal, third person, and free of frequent informal phrasing.
39 Alignment
The same problem, constructs, method, and design run through the whole manuscript.
40 Document structure
The abstract, table of contents, five chapters, and references are present.

Score total: appears after review