Dissertation
This is one dissertation rubric. It combines the academic-review list, the subject-matter list, and the evaluation list, and it drops items that belong to a single school. A manuscript usually has front matter (title page, abstract, table of contents), five chapters, references, and any appendices, in APA 7. Chapter 1 introduces the problem, purpose, framework, research questions, significance, and key terms. Chapter 2 explains the search and reviews the literature by theme, including the framework. Chapter 3 describes the design, sample, instruments, procedures, analysis, and ethics in enough detail to repeat the study. Chapter 4 reports results by research question and compares them with the literature. Chapter 5 discusses the findings, makes recommendations, and closes with a conclusion.
An uploaded template is added beside this type. It does not replace it. 40 criteria.
Headings
- Title page
- Abstract
- Table of contents
- Chapter 1 opening
- Statement of the Problem
- Purpose of the Study
- Introduction to the Framework
- Nature of the Study
- Research Questions
- Hypotheses
- Significance of the Study
- Definition of Key Terms
- Chapter 1 summary
- Chapter 2 opening and literature search
- Literature review
- Theoretical or conceptual framework
- Chapter 2 summary
- Research Methodology and Design
- Population and Sample
- Materials or Instrumentation
- Study Procedures
- Data Analysis
- Ethical Assurances
- Results
- Evaluation of Findings
- Discussion
- Recommendations for Practice
- Recommendations for Future Research
- Conclusions
- References
- Appendices
| # | Criterion | Meets | Partially meets | Does not meet |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Chapter 1 opening The chapter opens by orienting the reader and is supported by literature. |
|||
| 2 | Problem The problem is specific and supported by recent scholarly sources. |
|||
| 3 | Purpose The purpose matches the problem and says how the study was conducted. |
|||
| 4 | Framework introduction The framework is named and explained with literature. |
|||
| 5 | Nature of the study Design, variables or constructs, instruments, analysis, and the reason for that choice are stated. |
|||
| 6 | Research questions Questions are aligned, measurable, and not yes-or-no questions. |
|||
| 7 | Hypotheses Quantitative studies pair each research question with a null and an alternative hypothesis. Qualitative studies do not need hypotheses. |
|||
| 8 | Significance The contribution of the study is supported by current literature. |
|||
| 9 | Key terms Definitions are cited and listed in alphabetical order. |
|||
| 10 | Chapter 1 summary The summary restates the need, purpose, and method, and leads into Chapter 2. |
|||
| 11 | Chapter 2 opening and search The chapter is outlined, and the search names databases, terms, and a date range. |
|||
| 12 | Literature breadth The review is long enough for a dissertation and uses current sources. |
|||
| 13 | Full framework The framework is developed in detail, including why it was chosen over others. |
|||
| 14 | Literature themes Themes move from broad to narrow and weigh where studies agree and disagree. |
|||
| 15 | Chapter 2 summary The summary gathers the themes and leads into the method. |
|||
| 16 | Chapter 3 opening The chapter orients the reader and previews its sections. |
|||
| 17 | Method and design The method and design fit the questions, cite methodology sources, and discuss alternatives. |
|||
| 18 | Population and sample The population, inclusion criteria, and, for quantitative work, a cited power analysis are present. |
|||
| 19 | Instrumentation Each instrument’s reliability, validity, and source or permission is described. |
|||
| 20 | Data collection Sample, procedures, analysis, ethics, and the researcher’s role are present. |
|||
| 21 | Replication detail Procedures and analysis are specific enough for another researcher to repeat the study. |
|||
| 22 | Chapter 4 opening The chapter restates the purpose and is organized by research question. |
|||
| 23 | Validity and reliability of the data The chapter reports trustworthiness or the checks required by the statistical tests. |
|||
| 24 | Results Results are organized by research question and stay descriptive. |
|||
| 25 | Evaluation of findings Findings are compared with the literature and the framework. |
|||
| 26 | Chapter 4 summary The chapter closes with the key results and leads into Chapter 5. |
|||
| 27 | Chapter 5 opening The chapter orients the reader and previews its sections. |
|||
| 28 | Discussion Each research question is discussed in light of the literature, the problem, and the framework. |
|||
| 29 | Recommendations for practice Practice recommendations come from the findings and the literature. |
|||
| 30 | Recommendations for future research Future studies are tied to this study’s limitations and the literature. |
|||
| 31 | Conclusions The close restates the study and leaves a clear take-home message. |
|||
| 32 | Abstract The abstract states the problem, purpose, procedures, results, implications, and recommendations. |
|||
| 33 | Citations Claims use current scholarly sources and avoid informal wording. |
|||
| 34 | References In-text citations and the reference list match, without duplicates or broken DOI links. |
|||
| 35 | Appendices Appendices that are mentioned appear in the order they are first mentioned. |
|||
| 36 | Tense A completed study is written in the past tense. |
|||
| 37 | APA format Contents lists and citations follow APA 7. |
|||
| 38 | Writing The voice is formal, third person, and free of frequent informal phrasing. |
|||
| 39 | Alignment The same problem, constructs, method, and design run through the whole manuscript. |
|||
| 40 | Document structure The abstract, table of contents, five chapters, and references are present. |
Score total: appears after review