This institution-neutral 63-element evaluation rubric combines the Academic Review Checklist (AR · 16 items), the Subject Matter Expert Methodology & Content Rubric (SME · 34 items), and the Doctoral Standards & Sequential Evaluation Rubric (DSE · 13 items). It serves as the default rubric across EnScribe's Dissertation Evaluation & Revision, GRADE (Professor / Committee Reader Comments), and Committee Response Matrix tools — or you can download the Word (.docx) file below, customize any criteria for your program or course, and upload your custom rubric.
| ID | Rubric Element | Meets Criteria When… | Scoring |
|---|---|---|---|
| AR-1 | Abstract | Contains the problem, purpose, findings, and recommendations (350 words or fewer). | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-2 | Ch1 – Research Problem | Problem is specified and supported in the literature; aligned with degree and feasible; uses standard phrasing: "The problem to be addressed in this study is…" (or "…addressed in this study was…"). | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-3 | Ch1 – Purpose Statement | Aligned with problem; contains method, design, geographic location, and sample population; uses standard phrasing: "The purpose of this [methodology] [design] study is to…". | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-4 | Ch1 – Research Questions | Aligned with problem and purpose; measurable, answerable, and well-formatted. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-5 | Ch1 – Hypotheses | Clear connection to research questions and statistical methods (mark Meets for qualitative studies). | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-6 | Ch2 – Literature Review Alignment & Flow | Describes databases, keywords, and date ranges used; aligned with variables/constructs; flows logically. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-7 | Ch2 – Literature Review Breadth & Depth | Current literature; synthesis around themes including how study fits the framework; sufficient depth for a dissertation. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-8 | Ch3 – Research Method & Design | Appropriate to answer research questions; supported by scholarly literature. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-9 | Ch3 – Data Collection | Participant selection clear and appropriate; ethical processes described; researcher role discussed; data collection and analysis articulated and justified. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-10 | Ch3 – Detail | Study design, recruitment, instruments, and analysis described with sufficient detail for replication. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-11 | Ch4 – Results | Organized around research questions; sufficient data to answer each RQ; no interpretation of findings. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-12 | Ch4 – Comparison to Literature | Evaluation includes connections to Chapter 2 literature and framework; findings tie back to literature review. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-13 | Ch5 – Discussion | Discussion and implications explained for each RQ; framed in context of literature, framework, and significance; includes implications for practice. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-14 | Ch5 – Recommendations | Based on study findings; includes both practical and future research suggestions. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-15 | Template & Structure | Document follows standard 5-chapter dissertation structure; includes all required front matter, chapters, and sections. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| AR-16 | APA 7 Formatting | Follows fundamental APA 7 for Table of Contents, List of Tables, List of Figures, in-text citations, and references. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| ID | Rubric Element | Meets Criteria When… | Scoring |
|---|---|---|---|
| SME-1 | Introductory Remarks | Clear overview of study provided; flows general-to-specific; major points supported by literature; framed for academic discipline. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-2 | Statement of the Problem | Clear problem explained and supported through Introduction; strong evidence (mostly within past 5 years); significance discussed in terms of local problem and larger population. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-3 | Purpose of the Study | Purpose described and aligned to problem; summary of how study will be/was conducted. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-4 | Intro to Theoretical/Conceptual Framework | Theory/framework identified and explained through literature; interrelationship described if multiple frameworks used. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-5 | Nature of the Study | Brief overview of design, variables/constructs, instruments, and analyses; explains why method and design were chosen. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-6 | Research Questions/Hypotheses | RQs directly answerable beyond yes/no; specific and testable; aligned with design and support problem/purpose; core concepts/variables included; hypotheses (quant only) singular, clear, balanced, specific, testable. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-7 | Significance of the Study | Contribution to field summarized; need for study described and aligned with problem; supported by current literature. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-8 | Definition of Key Terms | Definitions with scholarly citations for dissertation-related terms; terms listed in alphabetical order. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-9 | Summary | Summary of need and purpose, method and design, anticipated contributions; transitions smoothly to Chapter 2. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| ID | Rubric Element | Meets Criteria When… | Scoring |
|---|---|---|---|
| SME-10 | Introductory Remarks / Literature Search Strategies | Reader oriented to topic areas; chapter outline and literature search strategy (databases, search terms, date range) provided. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-11 | Full Theoretical/Conceptual Framework | Theories/frameworks covered in detail; seminal and current sources described; rationale for framework choice substantiated against alternatives. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-12 | Themes or Subtopics | Themes arranged logically; broad-to-narrow within each theme; critically evaluates convergence and divergence in literature rather than listing studies one by one. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-13 | Summary | All relevant information covered; refers to major themes from Introduction; prepares reader for the methodology chapter. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| ID | Rubric Element | Meets Criteria When… | Scoring |
|---|---|---|---|
| SME-14 | Introductory Remarks | Reader oriented to topics; chapter outline presented; all major themes/concepts introduced. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-15 | Research Methodology and Design | Method and design aligned with problem, purpose, and RQs; scholarly support for design choice; alternative designs discussed. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-16 | Population and Sample | Target population described with relation to larger population; inclusion/exclusion criteria noted; power analysis described and cited (quant). | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-17 | Materials/Instrumentation | Instruments described including origin, reliability, and validity; permissions or public-domain source included (quant); expert review/protocol described (qual). | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| ID | Rubric Element | Meets Criteria When… | Scoring |
|---|---|---|---|
| SME-18 | Introductory Remarks | Adequate overview of study purpose; chapter organized around RQs/hypotheses. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-19 | Trustworthiness/Validity and Reliability | Describes validity and reliability of data; factors impacting interpretation noted; covers assumptions of statistical tests (quant). | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-20 | Results | Results presented in line with RQs/hypotheses; structured and organized; minimal interpretation; tables and figures used appropriately. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-21 | Evaluation of Findings (Brief) | Findings interpreted; theoretical/conceptual framework discussed; findings compared to Chapter 2 scholarly literature. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-22 | Summary | Chapter concludes with organized summary of key points and transitions to Chapter 5. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| ID | Rubric Element | Meets Criteria When… | Scoring |
|---|---|---|---|
| SME-23 | Introductory Remarks | Reader oriented to topic areas; chapter outline presented; all major themes introduced. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-24 | Implications (Discussion of Findings) | Findings discussed by RQ and hypotheses; clear conclusions based on actual findings; framed in context of literature, problem, purpose, framework, and significance. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-25 | Recommendations for Practice | Recommendations for applying findings to practice/theory; supported by Chapter 2 literature connections. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-26 | Recommendations for Future Research | Based on framework, findings, and implications; explains what future researchers should do; tied to scholarly literature; discusses how to improve on this study’s limitations. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-27 | Conclusions / Study Summary | Descriptive conclusion summarizing study, importance, and problem addressed; includes clear take-home message for professional and academic stakeholders. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| ID | Rubric Element | Meets Criteria When… | Scoring |
|---|---|---|---|
| SME-28 | Abstract | Contains problem, purpose, findings, and recommendations; 350 words or fewer. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-29 | Citations | Current (at least 80% within 5 years, seminal works excepted), relevant, scholarly; all claims substantiated; no personal opinion, bias, anthropomorphisms, or informal language. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-30 | References | Aligned in-text-to-reference-list and vice versa; proper https://doi.org/ notation; all references exist; no duplicates. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-31 | Appendices | Appropriate to manuscript; alignment between text and appendices; lettered in order of first mention. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-32 | Tense | All discussions of the completed study written in past tense. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-33 | APA 7 Format | Standard dissertation template requirements followed; fundamental APA 7 consistently applied for TOC, List of Tables, List of Figures, citations, references, and appendices. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| SME-34 | Writing/Presentation | Follows conventions of scholarly writing, grammar, and punctuation; formal third-person academic voice with no anthropomorphisms or contractions. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| ID | Rubric Element | Meets Criteria When… | Scoring |
|---|---|---|---|
| DSE-1 | Chapter 1 Complete | All Chapter 1 elements (SME 1–9) are included and meet committee standards; all prior feedback addressed. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-2 | Chapter 2 Complete | All Chapter 2 elements (SME 10–13) are included and meet committee standards; all prior feedback addressed. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-3 | Chapter 3 Complete | All Chapter 3 elements (SME 14–17) are included and meet committee standards; all prior feedback addressed. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-4 | Chapter 4 Complete | All Chapter 4 elements (SME 18–22) are included and meet committee standards; all prior feedback addressed. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-5 | Chapter 5 Complete | All Chapter 5 elements (SME 23–27) are included and meet committee standards; all prior feedback addressed. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-6 | Manuscript Alignment | Problem, purpose, framework, research questions, hypotheses, method/design, findings, and recommendations are aligned verbatim and conceptually throughout the manuscript. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-7 | Abstract | 350 words or fewer; contains problem, purpose, procedures, results, implications, and recommendations. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-8 | Citations | Current (at least 80% within 5 years), relevant, scholarly; claims substantiated; no personal opinion, bias, or informal language. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-9 | References | Aligned text-to-reference-list; proper https://doi.org/ notation; all references exist without duplication; all links working. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-10 | Appendices | Appropriate and organized; alignment between text and appendices; lettered in correct order. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-11 | Tense | All discussions of completed study written in past tense. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-12 | APA 7 Format | Standard template requirements followed; fundamental APA 7 consistently applied throughout (TOC, List of Tables, List of Figures, citations, references, appendices). | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |
| DSE-13 | Writing/Presentation | Follows scholarly writing conventions, grammar, and punctuation; infrequent anthropomorphisms and informal language. | Meets: 1.00 pt Not Met: 0.01 pt |